+1 (216) 401-7533

‘My Other Bag’ Isn’t Funny: Louis Vuitton Files with Supreme Court

WASHINGTON — On 13 July 2017, Louis Vuitton filed a petition for a writ of certiorari with the U.S. Supreme Court to hear its case against My Other Bag (“MOB”), a small L.A. brand known for its designer bag-on-canvas styles.

According to the petition, “Louis Vuitton has devoted more than a century to developing, promoting, and protecting trademarks that are universally recognized symbols of the company’s products and that constitute a guarantee of the products’ origin and quality.”

Louis Vuitton further asserts, “MOB sought to capitalize on the distinctiveness and positive public perception of Louis Vuitton’s marks by marketing otherwise-ordinary canvas bags bearing its famous marks on one side and the words ‘My Other Bag…’ on the other. In so doing, MOB created a risk that the public will no longer associate Louis Vuitton’s marks only with Louis Vuitton’s high-end products but will also associate the marks with MOB’s bags [emphasis added].”

It goes on to say, “Permitting an entire business model premised on the exploitation of famous marks to sell knock-off products is flatly at odds with Congress’s intent to protect famous marks from dilution [emphasis added].”

On 22 December 2016, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York’s January 2016 ruling that MOB’s bags are covered by the parody defense.

“Thus, the Supreme Court would be tasked with coming up with a suitable test for deciding whether an apparently dilutive use of a trademark is protected by the parody defense.”

 

Louis Vuitton notes, “the question presented in this case has far-reaching significance for countless owners of famous and distinctive marks that, like Louis Vuitton, depend on the protections of the [Trademark Dilution Revision Act (“TDRA”)] to safeguard their intellectual property against improper dilutive uses [link added].”

In its original suit, Louis Vuitton references a dilution-by-blurring claim against MOB “to protect the distinctiveness of its marks.” (It is important to note that dilution is present when an organisation uses a trademark that is sufficiently similar to a famous mark in a way that it harms consumer perception of the famous mark.) However, the Second Circuit held that MOB’s use of Louis Vuitton’s marks is not actionable because it supposedly constitutes “parody” and thus, is fair use.

Louis Vuitton believes this “created a direct conflict” with case law in the Fourth Circuit “regarding the test for identifying parody under the TDRA.” The Petitioner goes on to say that “The Fourth Circuit [court] requires that a parody immediately convey that the famous mark owner’s products and the unauthorized products are different and immediately communicate a joke that confirms that the unauthorized use is intended for an expressive purpose … The Second Circuit required neither of these elements when it concluded that MOB’s use of Louis Vuitton’s marks is a parody [emphasis added].”

Louis Vuitton believes that MOB does not satisfy this requirement, as it was not until this litigation that “MOB added language to its website claiming that it was ‘playfully parodying‘ designer handbags.”

Further, “MOB uses social media to promote its products to fans of Louis Vuitton, repeatedly featuring Louis Vuitton bags in its marketing, either by themselves or next to an MOB bag depicting a Louis Vuitton bag, in order to cement an association among consumers between Louis Vuitton and MOB [emphasis added].”

Photo: Pinterest

Nevertheless, the Second Circuit felt that the parody exception “is available even if the purported parody is ‘gentle’ or even ‘complimentary.'”

Louis Vuitton disdains the Second Circuit’s aforementioned belief, stating that the Circuit’s “novel conception of parody…creates a significant uncertainty for all owners of famous marks, who are confronted with divergent parody tests depending on the jurisdiction in which suit is filed [emphasis added].”

The Petitioner goes on to say, “The Second Circuit’s decision vastly expands the fair-use exception beyond the narrow bounds that Congress intended, leaving famous marks vulnerable to widespread dilution through the production of imitation products marketed under the guise of ‘parody.’ The spread of products like those at issue here—designed to appeal to fans of the products that are supposedly being parodied rather than comment on, criticize, or make fun of those products—presents exactly the type of harm that the TDRA was designed to prevent, the slow loss of the distinctiveness of the famous mark [emphasis added].”

Louis Vuitton also disagrees with the Second Circuit in other ways, including that its “adoption of its capacious parody test restricts the availability of trademark dilution claims” and its “approach to parody is also fundamentally inconsistent with the TDRA because it confuses trademark dilution with trademark infringement by relying on considerations—such as likelihood of confusion—that Congress has made clear have no relevance in the dilution setting [emphasis added].”

The Petitioner insists that the Supreme Court’s “intervention is necessary to establish a nationally uniform test for identifying parody in dilution cases, to restore the careful balance between trademark protection and First Amendment rights that Congress struck in the TDRA, and to prevent widespread, irreversible devaluation of famous marks [emphasis added].”

Timeless Trademark™ hopes the Supreme Court decides to grant certiorari and hear the appeal from the lower court, which requires the votes of four justices.

 

Blog Comments

stromectol 3 mg tablets price ivermectin without a doctor prescription stromectol price usa

tadalafil best price 20 mg cialis 20mg cialis coupon

viagra pills sildenafil 100 mg lowest price sildenafil citrate 100mg for sale

stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 12 mg tablets

india pharmacy mail order generic drugs without doctor’s prescription buy medication online from india

ed treatment drugs generic ed drugs erection pills that work

india pharmacies online buy prescription online from india buy prescription online from india

canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online ordering prescription drugs from canada buy prescription drugs online cheap

trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online safe

best drug for ed ed pills that work best ed medication

Poker jest grą należącą do grupy gier o sumie zerowej(np. szachy) dla której możemy zastosować Equalibrum Nasha – już sam ten fakt wyklucza pokera z systemów zwanych potocznie hazardowymi. Ciekawiło mnie, czemu spędza czas na grze, w którą notorycznie przegrywa, więc z ciekawości sprawdziłem, jakie informację znajdę o pokerze w internecie… okazało się, że są pewne zasady, strategie i przede wszystkim, że gra opiera się na statystyce i dzięki wiedzy, lepszy gracz w długim okresie zawsze pokona słabszego. To mnie zafascynowało, zacząłem czytać tak dużo materiałów jak tylko mogłem znaleźć – nie grając. Po kilku miesiącach, zacząłem podpowiadać koledze podczas jego gry – mimo, że sam dalej nie grałem – a on przestał przegrywać Później poszło już naturalnie, był to rok 2006 2007 – dawno temu. https://collegeslp.com/community/profile/tarahtowner410/ Ta najsilniejsza konfiguracja kart obejmuje pięć kolejnych kart w jednym kolorze. To jednak nie jedyny warunek. Dowolne pięć kart w tym samym kolorze, które następują po sobie to zwykły poker. Koniecznie naucz się rozróżniać to od strita – w przypadku którego kolor nie ma znaczenia. Poker królewski charakteryzuje się tym, że zaczyna się od najsilniejszej karty w talii, czyli od asa. Dla jasności, kolejność kart musi być następująca: Poker to jedna z najpopularniejszych gier świata. Nawet te osoby, które aż do teraz nie miały okazji doświadczyć tej formy rozrywki na własnej skórze, najczęściej mają choćby szczątkową wiedzę na temat tego, na czym polega rozgrywka. Hierarchia układów w pokerze jest często wykorzystywana w formie swoistej alegorii dla różnych wydarzeń. Kombinacja „poker królewski” to doskonałe określenie osiągniętego sukcesu, tak jak „szach i mat” u szachisty.

cheap propecia online propecia pills drug finasteride

propecia 1mg generic generic propecia no prescription propecia 1mg tablets

buy ivermectin for humans ivermectin goodrx ivermectin 6mg

canadian pharmacy online ed meds online without doctor prescription mexican pharmacy without prescription

Unser zubehör produkt umfassen: Joystick, Druckknopf, Mikroschalter, Lautsprecher, Kühlerlüfter, Münzprüfer, Netzteil, Kabelhalter, Jamma-Kabelbaum, Leiterplattenfüße, Trackball, Schlösser, Münztür, Konverterplatine und so weiter. Umbau von Leonhart Pool Billardtischen für mechanische oder elektronische Münzprüfer. Wir können nun einen Schalter dafür einbauen jedoch ist die lösung sehr praktisch da wir keine veränderungen mehr am Automat durchführen müssen.Hat den vorteil beim verkauf das wir den Schalter wieder Aktivieren und den Stecker wieder auf den Münzprüfer stecken. Wir können nun einen Schalter dafür einbauen jedoch ist die lösung sehr praktisch da wir keine veränderungen mehr am Automat durchführen müssen.Hat den vorteil beim verkauf das wir den Schalter wieder Aktivieren und den Stecker wieder auf den Münzprüfer stecken. https://wiki-global.win/index.php/Roulette_spielen_mit_geld Ausschlaggebend beim Roulette ist die Software. Wenn sie nicht einwandfrei funktioniert und schnell läuft, ist kein erfolgreiches Spiel möglich. In virtuellen Spielehallen gibt es verschiedene Roulette Versionen. Besonders hervorzuheben ist die des Französische Roulette, weil sie zu den besten gehört, die man derzeit zum Roulette Spielen finden kann. Besonders praktisch für Systemspieler ist, dass viele Statistiken und hilfreiche Werte im “Erweiterten Modus” angezeigt werden. Wir möchten Ihnen nur direkt mitteilen, dass es schwer ist mit einem Gratis Bonusgewinne zu erzielen. Sie können schon gewinnen, aber Sie müssen den Bonus mehrfach umsetzen. Normalerweise gelten die Bonusangebote nur bei Spielautomaten zu 100%. Bei Tischspielen meist nur bis zu 10% oder 20%. Dies bedeutet, wenn Sie sich die Gewinne auszahlen lassen möchten, müssen Sie längere Zeit spielen. Falls Sie den Gratisbonus nur nutzen, um damit zu üben, müssen Sie nichts freispielen. Dies ist meist sogar der bessere Weg, weil man in Folge nicht so versteift an die Sache rangeht. Gewinnen Sie trotzdem etwas, dürfen Sie sich darüber freuen. Falls nicht, dann eben nicht. So einfach ist das.

prescription drugs canadian drugstore online buy anti biotics without prescription

ivermectin for humans what is stromectol ivermectin cream cost

natural pills for ed ed pills for sale the best ed pill

pills erectile dysfunction cialis without doctor prescription drug prices

buy prednisone without a prescription generic prednisone prednisone 300mg

buy ed pills is ed reversible buying pills online

purchase ivermectin ivermectin cvs ivermectin pour on for fleas

original cialis com cialis 20 mg best price cialis black australia

So if you want the whole of your conservatory, both inside and outside looking brand new again give us a call today on 01744 333 002 for a free quote! With over 25 years of experience cleaning both domestic and commercial properties in and around the Nottingham area. At the premium end of the cleaning scale is the so-called “Conservatory Valet”. This is where the entire conservatory is deep cleaned, inside and out, plus the gutters, window and door openers and also the frames. In addition, a special Upvc frame cleaner and protector is used on the plastic trims to rejuvenate the colour and offer ongoing protection. A glass cleaner that leaves a protective film on the glass can also be applied. Our window cleaners are trained and experienced to clean the windows inside a house with excellent results every time. If you also want them to clean the windows on the outside, they will only be able to do it if the windows open from inside and don’t need to lean on window sills. https://forumayamlaga.com/profile/qtdbella5445429/ We also understand that the secret to a great cleaning service is finding the perfect match for each customer. We carefully hand pick every one of our cleaners and do everything we can to make sure they are capable of providing the excellent service we strive for. In general, we only look for cleaners who have been cleaning for 2+ years, extremely professional, but also fun and friendly at the same time. There are 11,000 condos available for vacation rentals on the Alabama Gulf Coast. This means that on any given day, there are 3000- 4000 cleaners working. Many of them are independent contractors, private individuals or students. Many of them are not on a legitimate payroll and are not covered by appropriate insurances. That means that if something were to happen when they are inside your unit, you could potentially be liable. At Clean Condo, every cleaner, inspector, and maintenance professional is a full-time, W-2 employee covered by our general liability and workers comp insurance policies. We also provide background checks and we require training for each of the cleaners on our team.

hims ed pills help with ed online ed pills

ivermectin gel ivermectin capsule

cost of prednisone 40 mg cost of prednisone 10mg tablets prednisone 20mg online without prescription

[url=http://cheapdrugs.store/#]ed pills that really work[/url]

does ivermectin kill ringworm in cattle ivermectin 200 can you use ivermectin on cats

ivermectin pour on for humans ivermectin dose for goats ivermectin tablet 1mg

ed meds drug prices cialis without doctor prescription

real viagra without a doctor prescription how to cure ed naturally canadian drugs online

vitality ed pills treatment for ed sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription

ed problems treatment causes of ed male erectile dysfunction

ed treatments that really work cheap erectile dysfunction canadian pharmacy

ed meds online ed problems treatment buy prescription drugs online legally

drugs to treat ed non prescription erection pills ed for men

Belleville Legal Notice: HighClub is solely a technology platform that connects cannabis producers based in British Columbia and other areas in Canada to people who buy marijuana online in Canada. We process orders online on behalf of these vendors on our platforms who fulfill the orders of each customers as per the terms on our platforms. Vaporization is an easy way to enjoy cannabis on the go or discreetly. Check out our favorite cannabis CBD and THC vapes, pods and 510 cartridges Sorry, this product is unavailable. Please choose a different combination. Depending on what type of vape pen you have, you may actually be combusting e-liquid or concentrate instead of vaporizing. Mr. Lescoutre said the department was reviewing benefits offered to veterans and “consideration will be given to whether coverage should be extended to disposable vaping pens,” as part of an effort to keep the marijuana program as “up to date” as possible. http://psnfusion.com/content/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=1537002 Another way to prevent getting this page in the future is to use Privacy Pass. You may need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome Web Store. YOUR CONTINUED USE OF THIS SITE FOLLOWING THE POSTING OF ANY CHANGES OR REVISIONS WILL CONSTITUTE YOUR ACCEPTANCE OF SUCH CHANGES OR REVISIONS. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE TO ANY CHANGES OR REVISIONS TO THESE CONDITIONS OF USE, YOU MAY NOT USE THE NEWLEAFCANNABIS.CA & NATIONALACCESSCANNABIS.COM SITE AND ARE TO DISCONTINUE USE OF THE SITE IMMEDIATELY. If any of these conditions shall be deemed invalid, void, or for any reason unenforceable, that condition shall be deemed severable and shall not affect the validity and enforceability of any remaining condition. These are the different roles we’re hiring for at Flora. Learn more on how to apply by clicking the button below.

clomid cost nz clomid without a prescription clomid 100mg coupon

can you order clomid online buy clomid online fast shipping clomid 50mg online

clomid prescription australia clomid medicine where to buy buy generic clomid

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright 2022 Bay Area Real Estate Information Services, Inc. All Right Reserved. Copyright В© 2005 – 2018 Movoto, Inc. All rights reserved. CalBRE #01517281 It’s our goal to provide the highest level of service to both buyers and sellers in Metro Atlanta’s luxury real estate market. It is our pleasure to exceed ALL your expectations during your next real estate transaction. Please contact us for the opportunity to buy or sell your next luxury home. Warm and cozy: Firepit outside, fireplaces inside – 34 photos of this 4,600 square foot home Copyright В© 2005 – 2018 Movoto, Inc. All rights reserved. CalBRE #01517281 The LeBron James drama off the court: ‘King James,’ at long last, has its tipoff time Costs $2,805 a month in maintenance; $68 a month in special assessments until December 2021 https://informize.com/community/profile/coralsxx7637972/ Richchi: Having been in this business for some time now and really observing the different ways that other agents sell, I always felt like I was expected to fit a certain mold – like to be sending out shinny mailers or randomly cold calling a potential listing. But that is not me. I have never done well with being put into a box – my personal brand, design, relationships and quality matter to me, but most importantly being authentically myself above all else. And I just could not bring myself to follow that “expected” path. “FIFTH X BOND is different from other real estate groups not only because of our hyper focus on connecting NYC to London, but also because of Peter and my passion for putting our clients above all else,” she continues. “We are not a team that is here to take on listings for the sake of having a large listing portfolio. Our focus is solely on listing well designed homes. We are in this business because of our love of beautiful homes and our love of helping people achieve their goals.”

amoxicillin 500mg price in canada medicine amoxicillin 500 where to buy amoxicillin over the counter

IPL betting is amongst the biggest and the best cricket betting available in India and if you haven’t tried it, now is your chance. We will bring you betting odds and predictions for every live match during the tournament. Read our analyses to identify who will give a powerful performance and then create your IPL content betting strategy. The odds change throughout the season as key players get injured, trades happen and coaches get fired. Line movements for NFL futures happen weekly, so if you see odds you like, it’s best to bet on them ASAP. The Packers may be +900 to win the Super Bowl in October but after a surge in November their odds could jump to +400 and you’ll make less money than you would if you’d bet them at +900. Now, the model has locked in six confident NFL best bets for Wild Card Weekend. If you successfully parlay its picks, you’d be looking at a massive payout of around 45-1. You can only see the model’s NFL playoff picks at SportsLine. https://www.thebluepill.com/forum/profile/theosiddons9120/ Betway is certainly one of the best betting brands in India right now and its cricket betting app is one of the reasons why. It can be downloaded for both iOS and Android, though users on the latter will have to get the apk file directly from the Betway site as it is not on the Play Store.  The Betway betting app comes in at a close second for players from India. Or, potentially 1st place if you are unable to download the bet365 Android betting app. You should have no trouble downloading the Betway Android Betting app with an APK download link live on the Betway website. If you want to bet anytime, anywhere with maximum comfort – install Parimatch App for Android and make money from betting! There are dozens of online betting apps and sites where you can place cricket bets and enjoy the rush and thrill that stem from it. Still, if you are one of the 750 million mobile device users in India and a punter at that, you will surely love to hear more about the best online cricket betting apps where you can get the best cricket betting. Well, if that is the case, you are in luck.

50 mg prednisone tablet buy cheap prednisone 50 mg prednisone canada pharmacy

best online pharmacy clomid HomePage can you buy clomid over the counter in mexico

clomid online pharmacy india best online pharmacy clomid clomid men

cialis mit dapoxetine genaric cialis with dapoxetine cialis with alcohol

where can i buy cialis 20mg cialis in malaysia cialis daily online

how long after taking ivermectin can you drink alcohol can ivermectin paste be used topically buy generic stromectol

teva ivermectin cream ivermectin argentina ivermectin for swine oral

cialis and viagra is cialis better than viagra cialis super active 20mg

when is generic viagra available woman in viagra commercial generic viagra from canada

do you need a prescription for female viagra does viagra make you horny is sildenafil as good as viagra?

I have been looking everywhere a post like this.

I appreciate you sharing this blog post. Really Great.

This is one awesome blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

Add a comment

*Please complete all fields correctly

Related Blogs

Posted by Liesel Schmader |
BREAKING: Louis Vuitton Wins Trademark Lawsuit
SEOUL — A South Korean court has ordered a restaurant owner to pay 14.5 million won ($12,750) in damages to Louis Vuitton for using its trade name and refusing to comply with...
Posted by Liesel Schmader |
Fake Goods Trade Now Valued At $461 Billion
PARIS — Counterfeited and pirated goods accounted for up to 2.5 percent of world trade, or as much as $461 billion, significantly damaging companies and state funds, said the Organisation for Economic...
Posted by Liesel Schmader |
Op-Ed: Fashion Designers Worthy of Legal Protection over Creations
Even in 2016, fashion design continues to receive little protection in the intellectual property arena. While designers' names and logos are protected under trademark law, the material items that they...